Skip to content
0

Your cart is empty

Choose the products you need.

Your cart is empty Keep shopping
Rainbow Memory Matching Game

Why shop at The Toy Chest?

On the surface, we're a just another super awesome independent toy store (Indiana's oldest, actually!) with high quality, extra fun toys and expert staff. For 54 years we've been bringing you all the best in games, puzzles, dolls, crafts, science kits and more to encourage play in people of ALL ages.   But this isn’t just a store. It's creativity. It’s an experience. It's a service. It's people who want to know you and work for you. What we really bring to the table is everything we can do to make your life easier and more fun. We build custom packages for every holiday. We personal shop for your birthdays. To see what really makes The Toy Chest special, check out the "Let us Shop for You" category under "Shop by Category." We can't wait to meet you and your family!

-Hilary & Emily

Shop By Category

Reviews

  • The Game Package – Your Key to Unforgettable Family Nights

    The Game Package – Your Key to Unforgettable Family Nights

    We needed to revamp our games since our daughter is getting older and bored withwhat we currently have. We have played a few of our games and so far they are a huge hit. I love that we get games that you don't normally find at your normalchain store. I highly recommend having these lovely ladies ...

    Kelly B

    July 18, 2024
    Revamp YOUR board games today
  • On-the-go Pack

    On-the-go Pack

    Extremely easy to workwith, quick reply back with great suggestions. Fast and affordable shipping.Great selection. Very knowledgeable of the products that they sell. A pleasure to work with. Will shop here again soon.

    Laurie N.

    June 21, 2024
    Prepare for your next trip
  • The Birthday Box: Your Gifting Fairy Godmother

    The Birthday Box: Your Gifting Fairy Godmother

    It is a seamless way of shopping without the crowds. These ladies are very efficient and helpful. I will be using them again

    Jacqueline K.

    July 9, 2024
    Simplify your birthday shopping

Our Brands